Showing posts with label PR. Show all posts
Showing posts with label PR. Show all posts

Wednesday, 11 April 2012

Lunatics running the asylum


During the 2010 FIFA World Cup, The French National Team, made up of some of the finest footballing talent in the world, many of whom had been world cup winners in 2000, crashed out of the competition in a spectacular act of self destruction.

Some claim that the (astrologically obsessed) Raymond Domenach, Team Coach, had "lost the respect of the dressing room".  Others claim that all the team decisions were being made by a cabal of senior players.  The quote that best summed it up came from one of the junior members of the coaching staff, who said that "the lunatics were running the asylum".

Recently, I heard the exact same phrase used by a partner (former partner, to be fair) of a large firm spiralling towards oblivion - "the lunatics were running the asylum".

Domenach's team had some of the most talented individuals in world football - the problem was that they were neither a team nor where they Domenach's.

Partnership is, itself, a strange beast.  The concept of the professional partnership was formed back  in the annuls of history, when small numbers of like minded professionals sought to co-operate to advance their mutual interests.

Going back to my football analogy, a bit like a group of friends or colleague, all of who want to play football, setting up a local team.  The formation of the team creates a body to which they may belong.

The model of partnership fostered a collegiate atmosphere with equity aforethought.  Partnership worked as the number of constituents was small, their shared a common endeavour and were happy to be both individuals but equal.

Local team, jumpers for goalposts, playing for the joy of playing.

Even today, small or niche firms or local teams exist perfectly happily within this model.  Co-operating to advance a mutual interest.

Whilst Domenach's team still only had 11 players on the pitch at anyone time, it's stakeholder constituency is exponentially larger than that of a local team.  Supporters, government, sponsors and a whole football federation all had expectations, investments and were answerable to. 

Unlike the local team, Domenach's squad we're more transient members of the team - coming in and out though performance or, often, their own wont.  There was no longer a nucleus of shared interest.  Players competed not just for places but for profile.  Without a nucleus, a team needs leadership.  Management with a clear and well communicated objective which put the team ahead of any one individual.  Such as Alex Ferguson at Manchester United - no player, no matter how good, no matter how big their profile, comes ahead of the team or the club.

Otherwise, behaviours become less social, individuals compete for dominance within the team rather than for the team. 

This also happens at some larger law firms.  Top legal/client relationship talent has a premium and is transient.  The mutual co-operation becomes less important but the owner/manager/player nature of partnership not only protects those who exhibit bad behaviours but, in some cases encourage it.  The way in which profits are distributed can encourage individual advancement over the firm progress.  Two excellent pieces this week by TheNakedLawyer and The Law Society Gazette demonstrate how this can manifest itself.

So how forward? We, you could become a full corporate, crystallise ownership and separate ownership and management.  However, does this really still foster Individual creativity that a partnership encouraged?  Some, at organisations that have undergone the change, would argue that it doesn't. Creativity gets lost in process and layers of governance.

The Big 4 Professional Services businesses are still partnerships.  They encourage and foster individuals to advance and innovate. However, when I asked a Big4 partner how it worked he responded "The only time I really get to exercise my power is when I vote for the new managing partner.  Once elected he is the boss". Clear leadership, providing direction.

Recently, at the Young Vic, Michael Sheen played Hamlet.  It was set within an asylum.  Characters being patients, staff or doctors.  The patients took over - it didn't end well.

Each organisation has to find its own structure but to survive needs clear leadership.  If not then we may have "...variable service, two dishes, but to one table: that's the end" (Hamlet IV ii)







Tuesday, 10 April 2012

The illusion of competition...



This blog is deliberately provocative.  I am not suggesting that law firms use "slight of hand" but seek to draw on an analogy that a lack of buyer control that comes from not focussing on what should drive buying decisions:
_________________________________________________________________________

Cry of the Market Seller:
"Oranges, £2 per pound".

I can inspect the oranges and compare the price offered with that of the stall down the road.

Cry of the Fairground Worker:
"Roll up, roll up.  Ladies and gentlemen, a fair and open contest for those eagle eyed amongst you.  Three cards turned over, which one is the lady?" 

They all look the same. There is no transparency.  We try to follow the dealers hand, but he always manages to fool.  Why?  His trick relies on the similarity of what we are comparing and his ability to manipulate our lack of focus.

In a market, the consumer is in control.  In a fairground, the consumer is prey to other influences and chance.

Law firms, essentially, all look the same - partnerships, charging for time and materials.  The model offers little in the way of transparency and the buyer always bears the cost of reinventing solutions or over engineering. 

You can negotiate the hourly rate but not so the number of hours or seniority of resource that may be used.  Leaving aside certain well commoditised retail offerings (conveyancing, for example), fixed price is never fixed price - based always, essentially, on a guesstimate of time and materials. 

In fact, as hard as you negotiate rates - the total spend year on year goes up.

Law firms have thrived on the similarity of models, the lack of real transparency, and the lack of focus of the buyer on value.

Proof of this is that, even today, some firms are able to leverage super-profits (top 10 law firms margins are between 30-50%) that their customers can only dream of. 

A natural oligopoly has been allowed to develop.  Whilst there are over 15,000 law firms in the UK, there is only the "illusion of competition" - there is a limit to what the current model can deliver in terms of market led price pressure.

Let's compare this to the airline industry.  Let's imagine I need to get from London to Edinburgh by tomorrow noon.  According to facelesstravelagent.co.uk, I can fly with UKBRUMMYInternational or Das Germaner for £158 or £177, respectively.  If I fly cheesyJet, I am initially intrigued by a fare of £92 but with "extras", included in the other fares, I pay £162.  The mean of the other two.
 Professional services are, of course, a more complex model and with ABSs on their way, the challenge for buyers of legal services will be how they compare what "legal value" they get for every £1 spent on "legal cost" across a multitude of models, offering the same thing.  

Legal value may be risk mitigated, contract rights protected or the operational effectiveness of a project. It will change for and be pertinent to each buyer. However, in true economic terms "value" can be measured.

Buyers who learn to compare these measurements will shatter the "illusion" and enjoy a transparent market where they can assess value and make informed buying decisions.

So, in the future, where would you prefer to buy your legal services.  In a market or in a fairground?

Wednesday, 4 April 2012

Brick-in' it!

"Mirror, mirror on the wall is Samantha Brick the fairest of them all?".


Not if you believe the 10,000 comments on the Daily Mail website in reaction to her piece “why woman hate me for being beautiful”.


Ms Brick's response to the public outcry is that it proves she is right and is the subject of spiteful scorn for her beauty. 


You have to ask yourself how can a seemingly educated journalist can get it all so wrong. The public abhorrence of her piece is not a reaction to a beautiful woman speaking out against a society which judges her for her looks, as she claims is the case.  Nope, the public are appalled at the unashamed arrogance of the piece and at her for saying it.


It is clear that Ms Brick has little or no comprehension of the social mores that most of us seem to understand: boastfulness, swagger, cockiness, bumptiousness or, lets face it, conceit is a turn off rather than a turn on.  Whilst the Daily Mail will delight in the level of coverage this piece has got, and Ms Brick may even profit as an anti-heroine, most of us would not want to be seen in this way.


I am sure that, when not writing for the Daily Mail, Ms Brick is nothing like the public persona she has created. However, her complete lack of judgement and seeming focus on what and who she is, rather than how she fits in with others is a failing.


So, what has this to do with lawyers?  


Lawyers are often seen as Society's pariahs.  We all have heard jokes about how greedy or distrustful Lawyers are.  Whilst funny (we all need to be able to laugh at ourselves) they do not reflect the majority of people I come across on a day-to-day basis.


It is, however, a question of perception.  True or not, lawyers have a reputation that reputation has stuck. 


There is a fabulous web tool called wordle (I am sure most of you know it). If you drop in a body of text, it creates a word cloud which gives greater prominence to the most frequently featured words.  It can be an invaluable tool when assessing client feed back to enable you to identify themes, for example.


It is also useful to demonstrate the subliminal message contained in websites and marketing collateral.  A few years back, I used to have law firm clients undertake this exercise with their website text and marketing literature.  


The most frequently used word, in almost every case...?  "We".


And who hasn't been at those lunches where partners have insisted on telling a relentless chain of "war stories" detailing their legal prowess and cunning, failing completely to judge the mood or ask their client "what are you focusing on at the moment?" or "what keeps you awake at night?".


Most law firm website sites, still, focus on what they are about, what they are good at and what they offer.  Marketing literature and tender documents tend to be no better and sometimes worse.  Mercifully, however, the war stories seem to be dying out.


What we all need to remember and ensure we project is not, who and what we are, but what we can do for our clients.  Less "We" and more "You".  


Clients want to know how lawyers will help them, put their needs at the centre of consideration and deliver the right advice in a service-centric way. Its not about the law or how clever the lawyer is but about solving their issue or challenge as efficiently and effectively as possible.


Lawyers can learn from Ms Brick's (appalling) example.  People rarely judge us for who we are but for the who we project ourselves to be.